Apple Butter Custard Pie

Apple Butter Custard Pie

Hello! Welcome to our new website design. For our first post, we thought it would be nice to offer you a gift. A delicious recipe for Apple Butter Custard Pie. We hope you enjoy this recipe and we look forward to giving you more recipes and stories in our blog as time goes by. Enjoy!

For pie: 9” deep dish single pie crust, unbaked

For custard:  lightly oil a baking dish or individual custard dishes

2 cups (500 ml) apple butter (or 1 c pumpkin puree and 1 c apple butter)

4 eggs

½ cup whipping cream*

½ cup milk*

½ cup brown sugar or ¼ c honey optional

½ tsp cinnamon, then  ½ tsp nutmeg (optional)

Preheat oven to 450.  Lightly beat eggs in large bowl.  Gradually stir in apple butter/puree, cream and milk.  Pour into a pie shell or a baking dish.  Bake at 450 10 min, then 400 for 40-50 min until clean knife inserted 2” from edge comes out clean (eggs are set).

*may substitute 1 c unsweetened evaporated milk for whipping cream and milk

It looks and sets the same way as pumpkin pie.  Maple syrup is nice as a topping to the custard. Enjoy!

A Special Treat for the Holidays:  Strudel topping – put on top of the filling before baking:  3Tbsp butter, ½ cup flour, 1/3 cup dark brown sugar, ½ cup pecans. Yum!

Please follow and like us:
error